CDFT for C60-rubrene


Just Got Here
Hello everybody!

Since quite a while we are trying to run CDFT calculations on a molecular dimer with C60 being negatively charged and rubrene being positively charged. However, we are running into the error "Unable to improve the multipliers" again and again. We tried it with the fragment version, we tried it with a minimum input. We checked all posts on similar problems in the forum. Nothing helped, but in 2006 there was a similar publication already on that using NWChem, so it should basically work.

Here is the output:
In the output it gives tons of " nbf_ao .ne. nmo " ending then "CDFT: Unable to improve the multipliers". I hope you can help us with that problem. We also tried a bunch of different basis sets but it never succeeded.

The input will be posted next since the forum thinks this message is too long...

Thank you and have a nice week!

Sebastian Radke

Just Got Here
Here is the input:
echo
start rubrene1

geometry
C 0.64836229 5.19626845 -1.97859955
C -0.73341822 5.61536899 -1.82754182
C -1.26882199 6.54845570 -2.78370528
C -0.53878965 6.95179527 -3.86815306
C 0.78629158 6.45590026 -4.07276046
C 1.35753643 5.61084571 -3.16122222
H -2.27202168 6.91804159 -2.63738481
H -0.96539192 7.64547783 -4.58070217
H 1.34128281 6.76158730 -4.94993849
H 2.36444353 5.25214555 -3.30977126
C 0.52355771 4.02847521 0.17994589
C -0.92365989 4.18691166 0.15975079
C -1.50627914 5.09479765 -0.77698133
C 1.26839082 4.44098505 -0.96893275
C 0.33427589 2.89897057 2.35396771
C -1.10312436 2.80280239 2.17906535
C -1.71503093 3.43855230 1.08627280
C 1.12990228 3.47494351 1.34987827
C 0.14641660 1.66218153 4.46050291
C -1.25647196 1.50712206 4.25185201
C -1.85512001 2.05113657 3.14774490
C 0.91086782 2.33473968 3.54561928
H 0.60705615 1.23545822 5.34133526
H -1.84521889 0.94642065 4.96531162
H -2.91342650 1.91741308 2.98854917
C 5.23199763 2.96348773 -1.76306171
C 4.11402414 2.14177827 -1.92487863
C 2.83922353 2.63873689 -1.64803930
C 2.66296953 3.95723615 -1.20737633
C 3.78696073 4.78227548 -1.07266693
C 5.06401610 4.28559321 -1.33700732
H 6.22347799 2.58026580 -1.96592287
H 4.22847820 1.11932917 -2.25915938
H 1.97090846 2.01065810 -1.77117143
H 3.65733959 5.79867283 -0.72999965
H 5.92619387 4.92522808 -1.20251705
C 5.30418578 4.02981470 2.23738586
C 4.84927099 2.77228996 1.82801879
C 3.49986796 2.57520350 1.53219965
C 2.59176055 3.63824886 1.61747753
C 3.05356464 4.89466675 2.03659899
C 4.40085529 5.09048805 2.34709873
H 6.35086253 4.18023448 2.46725779
H 5.54388308 1.94830589 1.73266278
H 3.15097286 1.60787297 1.20562803
H 2.35031245 5.71368216 2.11135102
H 4.74332747 6.06531691 2.66976472
C -5.40658540 6.75391518 -0.03166506
C -5.21618326 5.91489416 -1.13440174
C -3.95782683 5.36994681 -1.39352554
C -2.87732625 5.63830631 -0.54262323
C -3.07574455 6.48549795 0.55857662
C -4.33030039 7.04305591 0.81180310
H -6.38312261 7.17522613 0.16786898
H -6.04751495 5.67768521 -1.78499604
H -3.81363631 4.70717604 -2.23471237
H -2.24136130 6.69463201 1.21483723
H -4.46774858 7.69554908 1.66443230
C -5.83492837 2.54229914 0.22166707
C -4.80826861 2.07177597 -0.60158059
C -3.48134956 2.39393033 -0.31437989
C -3.15763518 3.17829625 0.80419671
C -4.19385793 3.63911265 1.62748118
C -5.52314397 3.33129953 1.33366501
H -6.86602083 2.30215488 -0.00197847
H -5.03834889 1.46048949 -1.46458774
H -2.68536242 2.04755701 -0.95682372
H -3.95398444 4.26245948 2.47690942
H -6.31371417 3.71355824 1.96572991
H 1.97371810 2.43584135 3.70073280
C 1.60173057 -6.47319331 0.45005668
C 2.34622291 -5.64763886 1.39123894
C 3.29662040 -4.84592673 0.63274443
C 0.73110359 -3.13301432 3.36318150
C 1.97874824 -3.72721959 2.90010648
C 1.70074363 -5.09907821 2.49935785
C 2.09259516 -6.18233222 -0.89006985
C 3.14065898 -5.17686206 -0.77727934
C 0.24427351 -6.71648040 0.65746372
C -0.42963378 -6.14489922 1.81517873
C -1.77264495 -5.75546593 1.40747279
C 3.68255634 -2.48914217 0.00474817
C 3.56207686 -3.53116528 1.01563981
C 2.88899707 -2.95945747 2.17400376
C -0.31666362 -4.13886637 3.25048555
C 0.28244959 -5.35355502 2.71604943
C -0.68230434 -6.67977277 -0.46575496
C -1.92914216 -6.08620876 -0.00225517
C 3.08385843 -1.27345705 0.53854308
C 2.59402860 -1.56303711 1.87982211
C 3.53418178 -2.80617473 -1.34551972
C 3.25603310 -4.17901205 -1.74444540
C 2.32914147 -4.14250109 -2.86772224
C -3.10209960 -3.70614777 1.04172599
C -2.34664882 -4.59161407 1.91832741
C -1.60266246 -3.76576046 2.85932142
C -3.25257186 -4.02333068 -0.30819145
C -3.13220829 -2.98123241 -1.31866237
C -2.45736343 -3.55263097 -2.47627559
C -0.01675366 -4.71525224 -3.38309599
C -0.96776833 -5.51683738 -2.62505861
C -0.21235193 -6.40180293 -1.74870571
C 0.44819403 -1.79777593 3.08037333
C -0.89358133 -1.41143773 2.66859827
C -0.77107666 -0.37603623 1.65592811
C -2.65226987 -5.23885425 -0.84113095
C -2.16112480 -4.94806037 -2.18125819
C -2.82642438 -2.33346604 1.44141401
C -1.89835846 -2.37078467 2.56472869
C 2.77795551 -1.92200220 -2.22179494
C 2.03401072 -2.74715608 -3.16304511
C 1.39896499 -0.99705630 2.32048010
C 0.64278160 -0.11821095 1.44277384
C 1.32618432 -5.10506666 -2.97556776
C 1.20534158 -6.14726459 -1.96535384
C -0.29987361 -3.37945115 -3.66529170
C 0.74768532 -2.37373227 -3.55237663
C 0.14824736 -1.15811152 -3.02022874
C 0.18720598 0.20294897 -0.95920401
C 1.11138539 0.16263376 0.16222099
C 2.35621338 -0.43164880 -0.30084868
C -1.16863501 -0.04361710 -0.75126601
C -1.91484435 -0.86534667 -1.69415639
C -2.86717978 -1.66625043 -0.93568762
C -1.54673682 -2.78541580 -3.20225816
C -1.26978477 -1.41233469 -2.80321709
C -1.65800894 -0.33647536 0.58497317
C -2.70930308 -1.33648667 0.47382313
C 0.85974485 -0.36989854 -2.11675039
C 2.20207674 -0.75998723 -1.70922001
end

Just Got Here
basis spherical
* library cc-pVTZ
end

dft
xc b3lyp
convergence nolevelshifting #sinnvoll bei CDFT
tolerances tight
iterations 1000
### Constrained DFT
# cdft atm_anfang atm_ende charge q
cdft 1 70 charge 1.0
cdft 71 130 charge -1.0

end

task dft energy

Forum Vet
Dear Sebastian,
I have just discovered that the CDFT implementation had a pretty problematic bug since version 6.3.
I have found the fix for it, and the patch for 6.5 is available at

http://nwchemgit.github.io/images/Cdft.patch.gz

I have modified your input file slightly and he modified file that will allow you to converge is available at
http://nwchemgit.github.io/images/Rubrene_cdft_tz.nw


Forum >> NWChem's corner >> Running NWChem